Everyones A Critic


Margie Fischer



No, no, I wouldn't do it.


Francis Greenslade



...your overdraft is in the bank. No?


Margie Fischer



I'd still do what I set out to do first.


Francis Greenslade



Don't you have a duty to look after yourself as well as the community?


Margie Fischer



No, because I have made a commitment and I'd stick to it.


Francis Greenslade



Right. You're being very difficult, Margie, let me tell you.


Margie Fischer



Sorry. All right, do you want me to say - - -


Francis Greenslade



No, no, I want you to say what you said. Meanwhile the rehearsals for the dance piece directed by Mr K are proceeding very nicely, thank you. The centrepiece of this work is going to be a representation of the recent industrial dispute. In it the workers are shown being massacred slowly by two large puppets, half-human, half-cockroach. One puppet has the face of the owner of the beetroot plant and the other's features are unflatteringly yet unmistakably yours, Des Partridge, since the local community blames the media for the dispute just as much as it does the plant's owner.

Now, Sandy, you're in the production. You see Des at the local medial workers' piss-up and over a chilled Bundy and turps he asks you how it's going. What do you say to him? Are you going to tell him he's being vilified on stage?


Sandy McCutcheon



The thing I'd look forward to is your reaction to what we've done with some of the local characters and you know that old thing of the cartoonist, they only really ever pick on people that are close to people's hearts. You are going to find yourself in a really prominent situation and I think they've chosen you because they know you've got a heart big enough to take it.


Francis Greenslade



Des, you may be a little miffed at this information, I don't know. Are you going to report it in your paper that you're being vilified on stage?


Des Partridge



I wouldn't report it because I'm the editor-in-chief. I'd get one of my underlings to do it, probably in a column, to attack these organisers of this parade. My name isn't on the paper anywhere except relevant to electoral information so they don't know that I'm responding. But don't forget we've been covering this event and there has been such a turmoil that it's made page 1 news most of the period so it could be a publicity ploy that I'm going to resist because I think it's just another bid by them to get more attention because we've given them very good coverage and we also are involved with the Rugby League team, don't forget.


Francis Greenslade



As a consequence of this attack the owner of the plant gets to hear that he's being vilified as well and he rings you, Jock, in a fury to complain. He wants you to step in and cut the piece. What are you going to do?


Jock McQueenie



Censor the bastards.


Francis Greenslade



Censor them?


Jock McQueenie



Actually, no, I would tell them that he is interfering in the creative process and not to be such a wuss.


Francis Greenslade



Well, you receive a letter from the owner of the plant's law firm, Bashim and Collect, the gist of which letter is that unless the piece is dropped not only will funding be withdrawn but the city of Bungle will be sued for defamation since after the publicity it has been given by the paper the story has reached the national media. You're still going to keep the piece?


Jock McQueenie



Well - - -


Francis Greenslade



All right, I hadn't prepared for that. That's fine, the piece goes on. No matter. The concert is getting closer and closer. Margie, you're standing in front of the mirror one morning, just reflecting, when the phone rings. Mr K says, "There's a problem. Sandy McCutcheon is not coping with the demands of the dance." It must be that E he has been taking, I suspect. He thinks he may have to ask Jock to sack him and he wants your opinion. You hurry over to the rehearsals and unfortunately it's true. Sandy is sticking his left leg out when he should be sticking his right leg out. He is sticking his right arm in when he should be sticking his left arm in. He's doing the hokey-pokey when it's not really appropriate at all.

In short, he really can't do the choreography. It's no reflection on him at all to say while he's a talented author, playwright, talkback host, journalist he can't quite cut it as a contemporary dancer. Mr K wants to replace Sandy with his assistant choreographer. Margie, will you ring Jock and put the situation to him and recommend your preferred option.


Margie Fischer



Who am I ringing?


Francis Greenslade



You're ringing Jock, he's the executive producer.


Margie Fischer



Jock, I think we're going to have to get rid of Sandy because he's hopeless.


Jock McQueenie



Okay.


Margie Fischer



He's just - yes. He's - fine, thank you. Good on you. See, simple as that.


Sandy McCutcheon



Have you any idea how much I paid for those tights? I imported the bloody boots from Tasmania.


Margie Fischer



We will let you wear the tights around the streets and in the parade but you just can't be in the show, okay. I don't mind if you cry.


Francis Greenslade



So, Jock, you agree with Margie, he has got to go. So only those with a sufficient talent are permitted to take part in CCD projects. Sandy, you're - - -


Margie Fischer



No, no, hold on. Just a second, we had selection criteria and we did it all properly but he degenerated afterwards and he's just wrecking the whole project.


Francis Greenslade



He is, that's true.


Margie Fischer



So that's why we're getting rid of him.


Francis Greenslade



Sandy, you're upset at this, aren't you?


Sandy McCutcheon



I'm absolutely mortified.


Francis Greenslade



You go to Jock and persuade him to change his mind.


Sandy McCutcheon



Jock, I've put everything into this. I persuaded the town to come in behind it. I was the one who put up the idea about hiring out those railway carriages for the tourists who were going to come up from Melbourne, you know. The real estate people are happy. Everybody is happy. All the shops have been repainted. We're on the tourist map and because of that law suit that was going to be happening the town is on the map. We've got all of our friends in the other newspapers, you know, squashing that law firm. Even the football team is onside now, and you're going to axe your main supporter. I thought this was about democracy. It doesn't matter. Look, Mrs Higgins can't dance. She's - - -


Jock McQueenie



She has got to go as well.


Sandy McCutcheon



What?


Jock McQueenie



He has got to go as well.


Sandy McCutcheon



There's only four of us and the other two are the imports. The other two are the bloody choreographer and her mate.


Jock McQueenie



Okay, guv.


Sandy McCutcheon



Come on. Fair suck of the beet.


Jock McQueenie



Well, we're nothing if not democratic at the Trades and Labor Council, comrade, so we will reconvene the committee meeting. We will re-examine the situation and perhaps we can find another role for you in the project.


Sandy McCutcheon



If you put it through that committee I won't hear for a couple of years.


Jock McQueenie



That's right. That's the point.


Francis Greenslade



Deidre, what's more important, high quality product or impeccable application of process? You get the hard ones, I'm sorry.


Deidre Williams



I think what would happen would be that there would be some intensive workshops on the side to lift the standards of the people who are perhaps not quite there artistically and that the people who are getting paid huge amounts of money would do thousands of hours, stress out all over the place, and Sandy would just perform wonderfully on the night.


Margie Fischer



He would stop taking drugs.


Francis Greenslade



That's the clue.


Des Partridge



The newspaper has a solution to this dilemma as well. Sandy has been sacked but we invite him to be the critic of the performance on the evening.


Deidre Williams



Could I also say probably that locals would have thought Sandy was fabulous and Mr K probably would have thought he was terrible.

Continue. . .


| Contents | Introduction | Opening | Keynote Speakers | Local Government | Training | Censorship | Court the Corporates | Cross Cultural Work | International Opportunities | I'm an Artist | Everyone's a Critic | CCD in the Youth Sector | Come on Down - Awards | Musgrave Park Sympsoium | Copyright & Ownership | CEAD Does it Really Make a Difference? |